DVD Review – Die Frau Ohne Schatten (Thielemann, Loy)

Strauss’ Die Frau ohne Schatten is widely considered to be a connoisseur’s opera. While the music is no more dissonant/”modern” than the more popular Salome or ElektraFrau requires 5 star singers instead of just 1 or 2, and the story is challenging for even the most creative directors. Despite this, it’s becoming more widely performed, and Opus Arte has released a DVD of the Salzburg production from last summer with an all-star cast.

Any libretto that calls for children singing out of a frying pan, flooded houses, and golden waterfalls (not to mention finding a Wagnerian soprano with no shadow) presents a challenge to the director – do you go for all-out special effects and realism, or do you simply ignore them? Christof Loy, one of my favourite directors, chooses the latter and instead bases his production on the recording process of the world premiere recording. At first, this seemed to be veering dangerously close to bad regietheater, where a director imposes his or her own story onto the music that has absolutely no relation to the story. Upon watching the video several times, however, I realized that this production is much deeper than that. Often, the Empress seems like a spoiled, selfish young woman who realizes the importance of selflessness at the very end. In this production, she becomes a much more interesting character and brings out some very interesting artistic questions. The Empress is a young soprano, very focused on her career, and the complete opposite of the Dyer’s wife. The Empress seemingly does not want to become the Dyer’s wife, who has sacrificed parts of her career for a marriage (which isn’t even going very well). However, this soprano, who seems to know nothing but her music, must record a part in which she has to emotionally connect to a woman who believes that marriage and children are the most important things for a woman to do. By the end, it’s ambivalent whether the Empress has changed – perhaps she has learned something about life from the Dyer’s wife, or perhaps she has simply learned to act better. And the audience applauds nonetheless – is there really a difference between those two? This production ends up investigating a) how an artist can connect to a character/emotion they themselves have not experienced or do not want to experience, b) finding a balance between a career and a personal life, and c) how external circumstances can/must affect art. Perhaps I’m reading far too much into it, but this production brought up a lot of artistic and social issues that I don’t think I would have gotten from a typical “fairy-tale” production. Besides, fairy tales are all metaphors anyways, so this one isn’t that far off the mark. And the best for last – Evelyn Herlitzius as the Dyer’s wife is amazing. Her voice may not be the most evenly produced, but she has a huge voice that she uses intelligently. She’s also a great actress, and altogether she

Onto easier topics to discuss: the singing and orchestral playing are all gorgeous. Anne Schwanewilms has often been accused of being a cold, uninvolved actress with a gorgeous voice. After having seen both this DVD and her Rosenkavalier one, I can see why people would think that, but the cold and aloof characterization is part of both productions. In fact, I find Schwanewilms to be a very talented actress – throughout this performance, she subtly changes her posture, movements, and even her style of singing to enhance the character arc Loy has developed for her. Despite a few hardened top notes, her voice is impressively even and beautiful. The Emperor, played by Stephen Gould, was also impressive in this equally demanding role. This role is perhaps comparable to Bacchus in Ariadne in terms of its high tessitura, so it was a surprise to hear such a baritonal voice in the role. However, Gould sang and acted well throughout the evening, especially at the beginning. Michaeala Schuster was a little over-the-top in terms of her acting, making the Nurse little more than an evil caricature, but her voice is undeniably large and exciting. Wolfgang Koch sings beautifully and elegantly in what can be a barky role, but a little bit at the expense of the character. And the best for last – Evelyn Herlitzius is an amazing Dyer’s Wife. It’s not a very sympathetic character, and it’s easy for the character to end up like a complete shrew. However, Herlitzius is a very good actress and has a nice voice with the appropriate laser-like quality for projection. In the end, Barak and his wife become a very real couple, unlike the Emperor and his wife, and are the emotional centre of the production.

This opera is also known for having a rich and thick orchestration, but Thielemann never lets the orchestra completely cover the singers. He still manages to bring out the variations and colours in the score, and there is finer orchestral detail in this recording than many studio recordings. I personally love Strauss’ orchestrations, and so it’s nice to have such detail in good sound. Even though this is an opera I first discovered a few years ago, this is certainly the finest DVD, and one of the finest recordings, of the opera I’ve encountered.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s